An example for testing medical Library Service Quality

Eva Klemencic
Institut for Biomedical Information - Medical Faculty
Vrazov trg 2/2, 
Ljubljana (Slovenia)
Eva.Klemencic@MF.UNI-LJ.SI



Introduction

The aim of this study was to find a simple way for testing the medical library service quality. For the example the searching was made in the field of communicable diseases and all of them were chosen as nowdays the most actual infectious diseases. All considering words can be found as controlled terms in the vocabulary Medical Subject Headings.
 

Methods

At first the number of bibliographoic data of some appointment infectious diseases that can be found in the most important bibliographic database in the field of medicine MEDLINE was retrieved. The included time period was as long as it is possible for searching this database from year 1966 until 1999 calendar year. The chosen years of above mentioned time interval were: 1966, 1970, 1976, 1980, 1986, 1990, 1996 and at last the complet year 1999. The next step of the searching was to find the frequencies of the bibliographic data for the particular infectious diseases when the name of the appointed infectious disease is the part of the journal title. For this reason the searching was made only in complete calendar year 1999. At last the result was compared to the journal collection of our Central Medical Library of the Medical Faculty in Ljubljana, Slovenia. All these journals can be found in a local area network of the Medical faculty
 

Results

The results of all searching steps as mentioned above were revieved in five tables and two figures.
 

Table 1. Communicable diseases
 

Name
Year
 
1966
1970
1976
TUBERCULOSIS
2326
2371
1597
TUBERCULOSIS, PULMONARY
1268
1252
832
LYME DISEASE
0
0
0
HIV INFECTIONS
0
0
0
ACQUIRED IMMUNODEFICIENCY SYNDROME
0
0
0
ENCEPHALITIS, TICK-BORNE
45
39
55
MEASLES
266
225
225
TOXOPLASMOSIS
240
246
239
POLIOMYELITIS
57
171
115
CHICKENPOX
4
75
76
ENCEPHALOPATHY, BOVINE SPONGIFORM
0
0
0

 

Table 2. Communicable diseases
 

Name
Year
 
1980
1986
1990
TUBERCULOSIS
1436
1492
1808
TUBERCULOSIS, PULMONARY
759
719
830
LYME DISEASE
0
148
318
HIV INFECTIONS
0
2543
6819
ACQUIRED IMMUNODEFICIENCY SYNDROME
0
2510
4649
ENCEPHALITIS, TICK-BORNE
44
29
45
MEASLES
204
231
267
TOXOPLASMOSIS
240
246
239
POLIOMYELITIS
96
119
120
CHICKENPOX
81
122
132
ENCEPHALOPATHY, BOVINE SPONGIFORM
0
0
0

 

Table 3. Communicable diseases
 

Name
Year
 
1996
1999
TUBERCULOSIS
2157
2137
TUBERCULOSIS, PULMONARY
778
749
LYME DISEASE
325
304
HIV INFECTIONS
6953
6199
ACQUIRED IMMUNODEFICIENCY SYNDROME
2225
1422
ENCEPHALITIS, TICK-BORNE
49
45
MEASLES
238
95
TOXOPLASMOSIS
208
224
POLIOMYELITIS
362
300
CHICKENPOX
205
179
ENCEPHALOPATHY, BOVINE SPONGIFORM
186
136

 

Table 4. Communicable diseases as a word of journal title
 

Name
Year
 
1999
TUBERCULOSIS
195
TUBERCULOSIS, PULMONARY
0
LYME DISEASE
0
HIV INFECTIONS
0
ACQUIRED IMMUNODEFICIENCY SYNDROME
178
ENCEPHALITIS, TICK-BORNE
0
MEASLES
0
TOXOPLASMOSIS
0
POLIOMYELITIS
0
CHICKENPOX
0
ENCEPHALOPATHY, BOVINE SPONGIFORM
0

 

Table 5. Tuberculosis and AIDS as a journal title word
 

Name
 
International journal of tuberculosis and lung disease
International journal of STD and AIDS
AIDS
AIDS care
AIDS patient care and STD
Journal of association of nurses and AIDS care
AIDS education and prevention
AIDS research and human retroviruses
Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome

 

Conclusions

This simple test can serve for example how the relevant journals' title can be chosen for medical journal collection creation as well as for recommending and nancellation. In this way the medical library service can be evaluated. The journal collection of our Central medical library in Ljubljana contains all of them.
 

Literature

1.  Constock GW.Snippers from the past: 70 years ago in the journal. Am J Epidemiol 1998;148:1166-7.
2.  Cook C, Thompson B. Reliability and validity of SERVOQUAL scores used to evaluate perceptions of library quality. J Acad Libr 2000;26:248-58.
3.  Desselberger J. Emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases. J Infect 2000;40:3-15.
4.  Lederberg J. Infectious history. Science 2000;288:287-93.
5.  Lightman H, Manilov S. A simple method for evaluating a journal collection: case study of Northwestern university library's economic collection. J Acad Libr 2000;26:183-90.
6.  Nitecki DA, Hermon P. Measuring service quality at Yale university's libraries. J Acad Libr 2000;26:259-73.